Skip to Main Content
Contact US


(713) 804-8149

Car accidents are traumatic events that can result in physical injuries, emotional trauma, and economic strain. In the aftermath of a crash, understanding the legal concepts of liability and fault becomes crucial.

This knowledge is essential in fighting for your right to a fair assessment of the crash and ultimately a proper compensation. This guide aims to give a comprehensive understanding of liability and fault in a car crash.

Liability and Fault: Unraveling Legal Responsibility

Ideally, liability means legal responsibility. Liability pin-points the party responsible for property damage and injuries sustained after a car accident. Therefore, determining liability is crucial in appropriating blame, and ensuring that the victim is fully settled.

Fault is a bit like liability’s close companion; it refers to the degree of responsibility each party bears in the accident. It’s about understanding who did what, how much of it they did, and how that contributed to the crash. The legal system often assesses fault based on concepts like negligence or recklessness. Recklessness and negligence can be defined as ignoring the level of care that a road user is supposed to exercise to prevent incidents that may cause harm to other users.

To establish negligence, certain elements must be present. The first is the duty of care. Every road user must exercise a duty of care to prevent causing harm to others. For instance, as a driver, you must adhere to the recommended speed. The second element is the breach of this duty. Breaching duty means not adhering to the set level of responsibility, such as failing to adhere to traffic rules. Causation, the third element, simply means that your breach of duty must be the direct cause of the plaintiff’s damages. These damages must also be directly related to the defendant’s breach of duty. A defendant cannot be held liable for injuries sustained by the plaintiff before the incident.

The Investigation Process

The investigation process is not always as straightforward as it may seem. It is a maze that combines gathering and analyzing the following information.

Scene pictures: If you are still in a good physical state after a car crash, please document the scene with your smartphone. It is crucial to take these pictures before the scene is interfered with by other road users or emergency medics. Document car damages and personal injuries. These will help increase the credibility of your claim.

Police report: In most scenarios, local authorities are usually first to get to car crash scenes. Besides helping the medical teams to help the injured with ease, their presence is an invaluable input to any personal injury claim. They assess the scene to understand the series of events that led to the incident, which may include noting down eyewitness accounts. After their assessment, they then proceed to fill their findings in a report. This report is a crucial piece of the puzzle as it is proof of the incident’s existence.

Eyewitness accounts: Eyewitnesses are like the narrators of the accident story. They have first-hand information about the incident. Their accounts provide human perspectives that can complement or challenge other pieces of evidence. Did you know that an eyewitness account can affect the course of your case significantly? Therefore, after a car crash, it is crucial to exchange information with eyewitnesses. Note down their names, addresses, and contacts as they may be valuable in increasing the credibility of your claim.

Expert Opinion: Car accidents can sometimes involve complex technicalities that require expert opinions. Suppose a plaintiff suffers from brain injuries. A specialized brain injury doctor’s input may be required to clarify the extent of these injuries and their economic and physical implications. Expert opinions add layers of understanding to the investigation, assisting in the fair determination of liability and fault.

Comparative Negligence: Sharing the Blame

Some states use comparative negligence to appropriate liability. This system holds each party liable for their percentage of fault. It means that each party can be compensated for the percentage that they are not responsible for. For instance, suppose you are found to be 20% responsible for the crash. In such a scenario, your compensation will be reduced by that percentage.

Insurance Companies: Navigating Compensation Terrain

Insurance companies play a crucial role in navigating the aftermath of car accidents. Most victims rely on this money to get back on their feet. Once you file a claim, the insurance company must conduct its investigations into the incident. But it does not end here. Remember, insurance companies are in business. They will do all they can to make a profit and counter losses. This is regardless of how faithful you are as a client. They will find ways to reduce your claim’s value, regardless of whether it’s a lie or not. Therefore, always avoid oversharing when giving your account of events. Some details may be used against you, affecting your compensation significantly.

The Legal Maze

Liability law is a complex subject. To deal with the aftermath of a car crash effectively, this knowledge is crucial. You must understand the legal procedures to follow to attain an appropriate settlement. Additionally, you must have a full grasp of your rights. For individuals with no legal background, hiring a car accident lawyer may be the only option to guarantee them a successful resolution.

These lawyers have dealt with multiple cases before, which makes them suitable to offer guidance. They understand what suitable compensation looks like, and hence will fight until you get what you deserve. Let us not forget about all the tactics used by insurance adjusters to reduce compensatory offers. Qualified lawyers can see through such tactics, counter them, and negotiate their way to a suitable compensation.


After a car crash, grappling with the legal aspects of liability and fault can be challenging. The best decision you can make is to seek legal representation and guidance. This will not only ensure your rights are protected but will also ensure you acquire compensation that is up to the actual value of your losses. Please contact us today for legal representation and guidance.


About the Author


Husain Law Firm

Nomaan K. Husain is the founder of Husain Law + Associates — Houston Accident & Injury Lawyers, P.C., a Houston-based law firm specializing in Litigation, Immigration, and Aviation. He is Board Certified in Civil Trial Law and Personal Injury Trial Law, with law licenses in Texas, New York, and other jurisdictions. Mr. Husain serves in key community roles, including as Commissioner on President Biden's White House Commission on Fellowships and Chairman of Houston's Asian American Pacific Islander Advisory Board. He's been recognized with several awards, such as the Global Leader Award from the Houston World Affairs Council.

Read More